Ah no…. it’s a bit more nuanced than that!
I’ve spent a lot of time recently sitting with leaders as they consider their 360 feedback, and there’s a pattern I keep seeing that might resonate.
Someone reads that they could speak up more, or be more consultative, or a little less hands-on, and almost immediately they swing to the far end of the spectrum:
So you’re asking me to just speak for the sake of it You’re saying I need to stop being across the detail. So I need to be much tougher with my team. So you want me to be someone I’m not.
And I find myself saying, more often than you’d think, that no, that’s not what I’m asking at all.
We are often wired for binary thinking, particularly under pressure. It’s either this or it’s that, I’m either getting it right or getting it wrong, and feedback can land like a verdict rather than information. When it feels like a verdict, the instinct is to fix it fast and fix it completely. A full 180 feels decisive and it feels like we’re taking the feedback seriously.
The trouble is, it’s rarely what’s needed, and it’s almost never sustainable.
I worked with a GM a while back whose feedback told her she was too far in the weeds. Her response was to pull out of every operational meeting and leave her team to it. Within a month they felt cut loose, decisions were stalling and she was quietly anxious about what she couldn’t see. She’d gone from one end of the line to the other and neither end was working. What was actually required was far more subtle. She needed to choose which conversations genuinely needed her, and in those conversations shift from providing the answer to asking her team what they recommended. Same leader, same strengths, a different emphasis.
She didn’t need a transformation. She needed a recalibration, and it made an enormous difference to her team and to the time she had back for the strategic work only she could do.
This is what I’ve been reinforcing in many of the Leadership Circle Profile debriefs I’ve run this year. The feedback isn’t asking you for a personality transplant. More often than not, the qualities that show up as reactive in your results are strengths you’ve leaned on heavily, probably because they got you to where you are. Your attention to detail, your drive, your willingness to step in, your considered quiet approach. None of that needs to go. What needs to happen is a clear-eyed look at what this role, right now, actually requires of you, and then a deliberate refocusing of where you put your energy and the areas you want to dial up to be more effective yet still congruent with who you are.
So rather than asking yourself “who do I need to become?”, I’d encourage you to ask “what is this role asking of me at this point in the strategy, and where am I spending time that someone else in my team should own?” What questions could I be asking of my ELT colleagues that might lead us to a better solution to the issues we’re navigating. What could my half-formed thoughts or observations prompt in my colleagues?
It’s a much more useful approach and a much less frightening one. It moves you from self-criticism into practical choices about how you lead, and it gives your team clarity about what they can expect from you and what you expect from them.
Nuance takes a bit more thought than a full flip. You have to hold two things at once, that you’re doing a lot well and that some things need to shift. Resist the temptation to throw everything out and start again or conversely, to have a big reaction and then do nothing!
It’s changes you make that people can see, that you can sustain and that doesn’t leave your team wondering who turned up to work this week that have the biggest impact.
If you’ve had feedback recently and found yourself wondering whether you need to completely reinvent yourself, I’d love to have that conversation with you. Nine times out of ten, the shift required is smaller and smarter than you think, and getting clear on it is the work I do with leaders every day.